I’ve been enjoying dipping in and out of the new Clubhouse app recently. Some of it is great, some of it makes me nervous. Is Clubhouse a beacon of hope, or does it have a heart of darkness?
Widely touted as the next new social platform, Clubhouse provides unique audio communication across communities and rooms. It’s cool. You can dip into lots of rooms and hear real discussion and Q&A type conversations. Put your hand up, get invited ‘to the stage’ and you can join in and ask questions to those on the stage.
But some things keep bothering me about Clubhouse. So I’m writing it down to see if it makes sense.
The Good Bits About Clubhouse
Multitasking Attendance.
The great thing about spoken audio is that you can listen while doing other things. Working, cooking, home-improvement, driving. This is where podcasts are so strong, and why audio will always have a place. And Clubhouse is good for that.
Industry Topic Expert Panels – like conferences, but without the terrible lunches.
The biggest positive for me is that it is enabling excellent industry subject-matter expert panel-debates. If you go to industry/tech conferences you’ll probably be familiar with the Q&A panel sessions. Sit 4 or 5 subject experts on stage, add a moderator that asks them questions, let them talk. Encourage the audience to ask questions and join in the debate. For a speaker they are easy (yay, no slides!), and for the audience they are usually interesting and sometimes very entertaining too. And this to me is what Clubhouse can excel at. Subject expert panel events running all day every day. It works really well and makes the old Podcast one way broadcast quickly feel dated and constrained. For these subject/panels, Clubhouse brings us the infinite interactive podcast. Really interesting topics too.
Get Close To The Rich and Famous
And then you can get close to some huuuge names. You want to hear Elon Musk argue with the owners of the RobinHood app that stopped the GME/Reddit short squeeze? How about asking some questions to Mark Zuckerberg? Kanye West?
The only global big name I’ve personally been in a room with was … Vanilla Ice! Really. Of course, I stopped, collaborated and listened đŸ™‚
(Update – another one. I’m listening a room with Deadmaus in it as I type this).
I heard some people saying how being in these Clubhouse rooms feels like an audio version of attending Ted, or a United Nations event. Every day. Special and interesting and valuable and accessible.
Whether with big names or small, I do believe that the industry subject-expert discussion rooms have the most potential to very very successful in Clubhouse.
So, there’s three good positives. So what’s my lingering concern?
A Heart of Darkness?
I see a different future for Clubhouse. one that is much darker. Like social media, but worse. Before you shout me down, let me explain.
Bad Thing One: Bad personal behaviour
Firstly it seems likely that some that antisocial behaviour is already present. I was in a Clubhouse room yesterday discussing how people use Clubhouse (very meta). I heard concerns raised about bullying in rooms, that some audience members asking questions were ‘belittled and mocked’ by the speakers.
Quote : “there are lots of rooms with lots of negative energy being spread… demeaning people by their looks…Clubhouse should be an inclusive app…“
Then the offline bullying. “I updated my profile to show I was gay… I started getting death threats…” “...obnoxious, bullying…“
So, already some pretty nasty behaviour is present, since it is being talked about. Of course it is very easy to be nasty when no one can see your face.
Full disclaimer. These are direct quotes from a room yesterday. I have not observed any of this behaviour myself. I also know the moderators are well coached to step in quick and stop bad behaviour so this could maybe be controlled.
Bad Thing Two: Snake Oil Sellers, preying on the easily influenced
Let’s be clear that many speakers on the stage are subtly – or unsubtly – pitching. Pitching their opinion, their vision, their brand, their business, their book, their site, their hustle. Not all of them, I get it, but plenty that I have listened to are passionate about their ‘hustle’.
Now, if that’s a passion in the context of the industry subject matter experts I described above then it’s good. A passionate evangelist for DevOps or LowCodeNoCode Containers InfrastructureasCode can be a good thing. They are educating the audience.
But if the topics become ‘how you can get rich quick’ ‘how to be successful by selling X’ it starts to get concerning. Gradually it starts to feel like those 30 minute info-tainment commercials on US TV. Or the evangelical programs.
I have not yet heard speakers directly encouraging Multi Level Marketing or Pyramid Selling schemes but I expect that to come. ‘How YOU can get RICH!’. Clubhouse provides an environment for that to grow.
Biggest Bad Thing Three : Socio-Political Impact
Here’s my biggest concern. I can see Clubhouse becoming a petri-dish environment, nurturing and growing unhealthy communities in biased filter-bubble echo-chambers, even worse than we see today in Facebook and Twitter.
When the ‘pitch’ in the room is political, evangelical and very charismatic and subtly manipulative it can become a big problem. Maybe you’ve seen The Social Dilemma: that docu-movie described how the echo-chamber filter-bubble of social media and fake news can be linked to the rise of conspiracy theories and even some extraordinary geo political events. Nationalism, populism, right wing agendas, q-anon, unusual presidents, exits from economic unions… And I believe that Clubhouse could very easily create more echo-chambers very easily.
Of course, the Clubhouse moderators should be stepping in to address ckear bad messages, but it’s hard to do that when the speakers on the stage are entertaining, charismatic and yet throughout subtly reenforcing their agenda over and over again. And if the audience support the message.
Those in the audience that disagree with what they are hearing will just leave the room silently. But those that stay are soaking up and supporting what they hear, just by being present. And their opinion is being influenced. And please don’t think that people are too smart to be led astray. Bill Gates injecting microchips, vaccines causing autism, face-mask being bad for you, 5G masts being burned down. Imagine Clubhouse rooms running every single day re-enforcing and re-enforcing the next conspiracy theory.
That’s what scares me.
More proof? Total coincidence, as I am finishing and editing this text I have Clubhouse on and I am listening to a room (the one with Deadmaus in) and they are literally talking about this exact topic. Echo-chamber conspiracy theory escalation from social media.
Let’s Wrap It Up
I’m a Clubhouse fan. Clubhouse is great, it has unique brilliance. I want it to succeed. I will continue to get more involved (hoping I’m not banned after publishing this).
On the other hand, Clubhouse scares the bejesus out of me.
If we get to see Clubhouse rules and administration changing to address those fears I will be hugely relieved. However, I don’t know what that solution can be. In the meantime I’ll keep using the app and keep on listening, nervously.
Image by Gerd Altmann from Pixabay
0 Comments